Can I fire someone if I have no documentation?

Yes, in most cases you can. Whether you should do it today is a different question.

I get this call more than almost any other. An owner has put up with someone for months, sometimes years. They are done. They want the person gone by Friday, and there is not one piece of paper in the file.

I understand how it happens. You were busy running the business. You kept hoping it would get better. Writing things down felt like a big-company thing to do.

Here is the problem. Every state except Montana presumes employment is "at will," which means you can end it at any time for any reason except an illegal one (National Conference of State Legislatures). The catch is the phrase "except an illegal one." If that employee later claims the real reason was their age, a medical issue, or a complaint they made, your defense is being able to show the real reason. With an empty file, it is your word against theirs.

The complaint an owner is most likely to face is retaliation. The EEOC says retaliation is now the most frequently alleged basis of discrimination in every sector, and its share of charges has roughly doubled since 1998 (EEOC Enforcement Guidance on Retaliation). That same guidance explains two things investigators look at:

• Timing. A firing that comes shortly after an employee complained or asked for an accommodation is often treated as evidence the two are connected.
• A reason that changes. If what you said in the termination meeting differs from what you say later, the EEOC may infer the stated reason was a cover.

Notes written when the problem happened are what protect you on both counts.

Three things to do before the conversation

1. Write down what you know now. Dates, what happened, who saw it, what you said at the time. Notes written today are worth less than notes written when it happened, but they are worth far more than nothing.
2. Check for anything recent that changes the picture. Did this person just ask for medical leave, report an injury, or complain about pay or safety? If so, stop and get advice before you act. Timing is what gets owners in trouble.
3. Decide whether one honest warning is the smarter move. Sometimes the fastest safe path is a clear conversation today, in writing, with a short deadline. If nothing changes, you now have your documentation.

Then have the conversation yourself, briefly and with respect. Firing someone is a skill, and you can learn it.

The real fix is boring: write things down as they happen. Two sentences in an email to yourself counts.

This is general guidance from an HR consultant, not legal advice. If you are about to let someone go and the file is empty, call or text me before you do it.

Sources

• National Conference of State Legislatures, At-Will Employment Overview
• U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Enforcement Guidance on Retaliation and Related Issues

← All posts